Sounds like mainframe thinking <cringe>.
Anyway, add a field to your table and make it's datatype autoneumber. It should default to a size of long integer and new values of Increment. Everytime a record is added, the value increments.
Caveats to your solution: Deleted records put a gap in the sequence. Editing a new record and cancelling uses up an autonumber.
If you showed the autonumber field and let them shoose between the field values for criteria, you might make them happy enough.
If they get really anal about not liking it, you can at least use Autonumber to sort the fields. Then for records 2 to 5 you can get the Top Values of 5. Then get the top (5 - 2 - 1) values of that query with the values sorted descending. It will take longer but it will work.