Right on, wolluf!
I didnt mention chkdsk but it was in error as i really like chkdsk and i dont see that it causes any problems at all.
I wasnt going to also mention that so many people bring their pcs in for service, tell me it wont boot. I ask them what they were doing. Too many times i hear they ran scandisk and scandisk told them it had to fix something, they gave the ok and now they have nothing! I hear that a lot. But my best customers dont see me as much since i told them dont run scandisk or norton (except for the norton a\virus). So i really do feel I know what i am talking about.
Also, to prove my point, my pc runs fast and i have had the same win xp pro for about 4 yrs now, i live on this machine, probably my 4 yrs years is another persons 10 yrs or more! And all is well, in my opinion, because i dont run scandisk\defrag or any of the nortons sysworks winfix progs. I put most of the registry fix programs in the same boat too! A controlled manual delete is better, and thats only after an uninstall, which makes it easy. Just search for the name or specific words from the program name or mfgr and delete only those items.
Norton goback is great, so is ghost and a couple others, the rest are junk in my opinion, and cause more problems than they fix.
Like you, wolluf, i feel so strongly about this that i do this rant, hoping at least one person will save having their hard drive trashed by scandisk! Or not spend hours defragging their drive for little to no gain.
Again, chkdsk is another matter, a good program, and so is fdisk.
I dont want to start a war, its just my opinion.
Good advice + great people = tek-tips