Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations John Tel on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

How do we use solver?

Status
Not open for further replies.

nqueen

MIS
Sep 21, 2005
46
CA

I have three formulas with three unkown variables and I want to solve it. People told me to solve it by using solver in excel. Does anyone knows how?

 
you are right Zathras ,there was a typo in my second equation. Actually as you stated, all my equations are the same, it s just the numbers that change. It is normal that the divisor is so big. the data is fine. couldI ask you what result it gave you when you did it (if you solved it)? and what is done by hand or by using the solver?
as I said, it gives me consistent results but with negative exponent which I don t want.

p.s. As for the other sets, it becomes worse when I take them. These 3 unkowns, 3 equations is supposed to be the easiest and most consistent right!
 
and by doing it by hand, using the website here are the results it gave me (let me know if I did somthing wrong please)

a=-1.3583919489848
b=2.8056754618695
c=1.38131596564621
 

All I did was plug your values back in the original equations and got these answers:
[tt]
449.1564802
218.5372175
113.1959846
[/tt]
which correspond reasonably close to your original 449, 218 and 113.

 
with which exponents? mine? if it is the case, this is fine but I need the exponents to be positive that s the challenge
 

Yours.

This is starting to get a little tiresome. As Walter so eloquently put it, with three equations and three unknowns you get either one solution or (@#!).

If you know that the exponents must not be negative then either one or more of the other constants are wrong, or the relationship expressed by the equations is wrong. Only you can determine which is the case.

 
Can you tell us what these equations represent? Are there large uncertainties in the coefficients and constants? Why must the exponents be positive?
 
You are right Zathras, this is becoming complicated, we will rather stop here and I ll try to manage with what I already have.. I thank you guys a lottt for your help. I am sorry if I bothered you. Please accept my apologizes and thank you again for your help and patience!
 

No apology required. No bother experienced. This was (and still is) a good challenge. Let us know what you find.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top