Good question. There are 2 scenarios where I see a benefit. First, a remote site "B" where an EPN is preferable to IP telephony due to survivability needs. Remote site "A" already T1 connected to the PPN is close to Site B, too far for copper, but not for fiber. Assuming that Site A to PPN T1 is not running at capacity, it would make sense to connect EPN B to EPN A thus taking advantage of the existing T1 from EPN A to the PPN. There is a cost savings by not running another T1 to Site B.
Second, Site A & Site B are 2 adjacent buildings. Both have T1 connectivity through different POPs to the PPN. The link from Site A to PPN goes down because of a CO issue. Having a standby fiber connection between EPN A and EPN B would be a nice business continuity feature.
This second scenario is the very scenario that prompted my question yesterday. I was looking for a quick solution to getting an EPN back up and working. I know all too well there are many other redundancy and survivability options... you can only propose so much, then it is up to the client to listen and implement. I did, they didn't, and there we were.
Avaya at one point said the EPNA-EPNB-PPN connectivity is technically possible but falls into the category of "permissable, but not supported". OK, been there, done that... not always the most pleasant of experiences to be left on your own to figure out what can be rather complex issues. I wanted to see if someone else had come across this configuration and made it work.