I wouldn't say there is one that is better than the other. It all will be based upon your port density and application needs. I use predominantly the 5400 series chassis due to port density and module application needs (I use the zl wireless controllers), but I do have a some 2910 series (for 1Gb users), and 2610 series (for 100Mb users) switches that are there for those outlying areas of my network where I would only have a few users. I use these switches to provide VoIP, IP Cameras, and wireless APs power over ethernet. Also, all of these units are capable of having the external 600 series or zl shelf (for the zl switches) redundant power supply tied on to them to offer additional power should the need arise.
We had a gigabit mandate, so we standardized on the 2520G and the 5400zl, depending on port density requirements. In areas where we have the rack space and available uplinks, the 2520G has been very cost effective
To be honest it depends if you are talking VoIP edge or backbone. If you are using the parallel port on most VoIP phones then these don't generally exceed 100Mb output so no real point paying for Gb edge ports.
Typically we use 2610 for edge connectivity and 5400 at the core and this will suffice for most VoIP installs that we would do (up to 500 users). Just make sure you do a load calc for the PoE to make sure you are not overloading the switch.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.