Solaris vs Lunix on x86

[gkout]

I think we could open this interesting thread on wether solaris or linux would be the best choice on a x86 system. Whoever responds to this thread please include the version of solaris or the distro of linux he/she would consider the best choice along with arguments.

 

[SamBones]

Great question, I can't wait to read the reponses.

I've just started trying a comparison myself. I have an unused HP/Compaq DL380-G3 that I installed Red Hat Enterprise Linux ES on. Everything installed correctly and cleanly. No real problems during setup and config. Ran some benchmarks and collected some stats.

I then wiped it clean and started installing Solaris 10. It wouldn't recognise the internal array (that Linux handled with no problems). No real problem, I just had to download and install some drivers during the initial steps of the install. It saw the array and went on. But, during the install, it would hang. I believe I just need to locate more drivers for whatever it's hanging on, but I just haven't had time to complete it yet. Need to do some more research.

So, my only experience comparing the two right now is that Linux was installed and completely set up in just a few hours. I'm several days into the Solaris install with no success, and no idea how much more effort it will take to install.

The DL-380 is pretty common mainstream hardware, so I would expect a little better support for it from Sun. Also, I'm not a noob, I've got several decades experience with Unix and I have a Sun Solaris Sysadmin certification.

I'm not bashing Solaris on Intel, I have used it briefly before and have been impressed with it (I like Solaris). But so far Linux ES gets better marks for the install process from me.

Hope this helps.

 

[gkout]

Regarding the x86 hardware issue, I must (u see i m a solaris fan too) that this is so far its weakest point. My x86 experience was on a Micron server (dual cpu) but no array. Solaris 8 installed perfectly with no probs. Even the on board NIC was identified. I have also installed solaris 8 on DL-320 server with add-on drivers. The only issue I had there was the tape which was on the same controller with the hard disk. I added an HCL listed SCSI card and I was there. Ever since I haven't faced any problems with these two boxes. I even have Solaris 5.6 running on a no-name Pentium II box.

I haven't tried solaris 10 yet to be honest. I will soon and post the outcome.