Been a long time since I used OS 9, but I believe you want to rebuild the desktop file.
Reboot the mac, hold down the apple and option keys during startup until it asks you if you want to rebuild the desktop file. Click the affirmative.
If that doesn't get it, I think you may need to use the, uh, shucks. Can't remember now. Internet Control Panel? It's the control panel that allows you to map helper applications, and it is either called Internet or its called File Exchange, in Control Panels under the Apple menu.
Not a great post on my part. Try the rebuild of the desktop, if that works or if it doesn't please post your experience here. I'll have the name of the control panel for plan B by then.
Thanks and good luck.