Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations IamaSherpa on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Media Tax 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

garwain

Programmer
Jan 30, 2002
461
CA
Sorry, I don't have the stats or links, and can't be bothered finding them. I just want to know what you folks think of the proposed laws to tax blank media including tapes, CD's DVD's etc?

I personally think this is VERY stupid. Also, I would be loosing a lot of money on this. To my understanding, the whole idea is that people are using this media to pirate music and software, so start charging a tax on it to compensate for the artists/developers. My first question is how is the money going to be distributed to the artists and developers? My second questions is why should the innocent be hit as well as the guilty? I don't pirate music. Anything I download is beause I can't find a recording elsewhere. I often burn a couple hundred CD's in a week. I do recording contracts for small bands that can't afford to do a professional recording. I'll usually charge them $50 or so to take a cassette, and record it onto my computer as wav files to make the master CD. Then I make the CD's as they are needed, in batches of 10 or 20. Now the lobbying of RIAA and whoever else is involved in this whole anti-piracy BS wants to increase my costs because people are pirating music? This whole buisness with the RIAA seems we will soon be guilty until proven innocent. What's next? do they intend to start charging EVERYONE for every song because we MIGHT hear it somewhere? If they RIAA is going to fight a crusade for the poor artists, I'd like to see them start paying more to the artists and spending a little less time lining their own pockets.

Another problem I have is with transmitting data. When I do a project for a customer, I'll often burn it onto a CD, even if it's only a few megs. Some of my clien't don't have high speed connections, so they don't want to wait for a download, and 3.5" are too annoying for anything over 1.4 MBs And what about my software archives? I have stacks of CDs sorting out the projects I've worked on, freeware/shareware that I've downloaded and often registered. Often when I go to a clients for tech support, I'll download the software I need off my cable connection and burn it to a CD because it'll take too long when I'm on the job site. Employers don't mind a $30 administrative fee, but they hate to pay you when you sit there for 20 minutes waiting for a program to download, then another 5 minutes while it installs.

Another personal favorite is with computer shops. I will never take an orriginal CD into a shop. let's see I have a MS windows 2k and office 2k... Do I want to risk a technician loosing the originals? I think not. Do I want to risk having it scratched beyond recognition? Nope...

So what do you folks have to say about RIAA, media tax, and such software/music piracy BS?
 
Resistance is futile! You will be assimilated! You will adapt to serve the RIAA!

I think that the RIAA needs to be dismantled if it is decided that such an organization is truly needed then rebuild it from the bottom. That'l do donkey, that'l do
[bravo] Mark
If you are unsure of forum etiquette check here faq796-2540
 
garwain,

Find the links and post them, please. Although a Canadian government organization is attempting to do what you cite ( and a German court ordered HP to pay a tax on burners ( I think that a similar proposal in the U.S. is based on an urban legend that's been floating around since about 1997. ______________________________________________________________________
TANSTAAFL!
 
I found articles relating to this and they were all many years olds.

Search in google using: Tax Blank Tape Media
 
In our country, this is already the case. I play in a band and if I use a blank tape or CD to record my own recording on, I have to pay to the music industry! Who's doing the piracy here?

Best regards
 
"Those taxes will go to subsidize artists"

Don't be fooled it's just another way to get more money in the hands of politics. Gary Haran
 
"In our country, this is already the case. I play in a band and if I use a blank tape or CD to record my own recording on, I have to pay to the music industry! Who's doing the piracy here?"

Absolute "#¤(/¤ robbery!!
I don't know how people get away with these things! Oh yeah, politicians, getting a percentage no doubt!


:: ::
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top