Well Chris,
It's an endless debate. Do you do what you think is right or do you do what your client wants? Of course you have heard of "Archives" in the sense of government or company archive where it is more than a word.
Not only will the web page be out of date, it will not be in existence except as an archived site. This archived site will sit on the client's site. The client wants their header footer and a notice that the site is an "Archived" site to appear, while at the sametime perserving the Archived site.
Using a frame set would expediate matters, actually make the task at hand a whole lot easier, but alas, do to accessibility issues, can't be using framesets. Lots of stakeholders to please.
In the end, the project will probably be a bit of this and a bit of that, trading one thing off for another. In the meantime, I am exploring all possible solutions.
Thanks for your thoughts,
Bob