Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations Mike Lewis on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Internal or External HDD

Status
Not open for further replies.

BRP250

Programmer
Sep 18, 2001
33
AU
I'm buying a 1TB hard drive to use to store media and backups. My question is which is going to be faster internal or external drives?

I'm at work so I don't have any detailed specs. The motherboard is about 7 months old a Gigabyte with 2 seagate 160mb Raid 0 sata drives. Checking inside the box I can plug a Sata drive cable into the mother board where the internal drives plug in. It has an AMD 9600 phenom chip and Vista +64 and 4gb ram.

If there's not a lot of difference with speed I prefer to go external.

Any information would be appreciated.

Thanks

Bruce
 
Generally speaking, plugging the drive directly into a motherboard interface is going to give the fastest data transfer rates. But what sort of external box/connection were you envisaging? If USB, then most definitely faster directly onto motherboard i/face...

ROGER - G0AOZ.
 
I really like having my main backup drive connected locally; speedy and safe from bad USB disconnects that can corrupt files. Of course, if you're a REAL safety freak, you can have both, an internal SATA data backup drive and a more-portable USB/FW/eSATA drive for offsite storage and rotation.

Combine this with spooled-off DVDs of important files and you're close to bulletproof.

Tony

Users helping Users...
 
Hello,
Here are some numbers to consider regarding HD Interfaces

USB1.1 -----------about 15MPS
PATA--------------About 100MPS/133MPS
FireWire 1394A----about 400MPS
USB2.0------------about 480MPS
FireWire 1394B----about 800MPS
SATA1.5/ESATA1.5--about 1500MPS
SATA3.0/ESATA3.0--about 3000MPS

SATA is internal
ESATA is external


I hope the chart above aids in your choices for your needs.
PCI cards for any of the interfaces are available, I
recommend a SATA 3.0 HD which would be a plug and play
and the fastest because of line looses that occur with
distance from the PC on any of the above interfaces.

Pete/Technician-now retired
Nicknamed "Einstein" by former co-workers
 
Pete - please clarify your speed nomenclature. I believe you are using MPS to mean megabit per second. And your PATA data rates are actually in megabyte per second, so that would rank it a lot higher than where you placed it.
 
Freestone*******You are correct Re megabit per second
I believe the chart should read

USB1.1 -----------about 15MPS
FireWire 1394A----about 400MPS
USB2.0------------about 480MPS
FireWire 1394B----about 800MPS
PATA--------------about 1000/1330(Maxtor)MPS
SATA1.5/ESATA1.5--about 1500MPS
SATA3.0/ESATA3.0--about 3000MPS

I have read that the next generation of SATA/ESATA
Hard drives due out soon are going to be even faster,
predicted to run at about 6000MPS. I do not know if
PATA is included in the speed increase too but I would
imagine so.


Pete/Technician-now retired
Nicknamed "Einstein" by former co-workers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top