I think your initial diagnosis of "Circles" fits the symptoms perfectly Dr Milkbar.
They are pretty perfect but that is merely an artefact caused by the platter's high angular velocity, and microscopic head dimensions, plus a very accurate electro-servo mechanism trying to read and re-read the damaged tracks.
Under an electron microscope, I am sure that they would appear to be deep and jagged incisions.
The patient is indeed dead, and ready for suitable interment or recycling. (I like the transparent body bag, by the way.)