Before you writeoff the handset, keep in mind that it's the phone software load as well as the system loss plan that determines what is being send to the handset. The wideband handsets would most likely require a compatible release version, what version are you running? What version are the wideband handsets compatible with (I don't know)?
I have a system with 9.0UR1 and don't hear a hum (5340 with wideband handset), but that doesn't rule out a problem with a particular batch of them. To clarify, you're having problems with ALL of the wideband handsets, or just some of them?