HP switches VLAN Confused

[moekad]

Hey please i need help!!

actually i've been working with Cisco products since 6 years and now i switch to HP products and i am pretty how confused but i need to make sure that i understand :

assume we have:

(PC1 eth0 vlan 2)====> ==> (PC3 eth0 vlan 2)
(PC2 eth1 vlan 1)====> SWITCH A (gig0) ===> (gig1 )SWITCH B==> (PC4 eth1 vlan 1)
(IP Phone eth3 vlan 3)

is the configuration will be as the following ??

Data vlan = 1
Voice vlan = 3
Server Vlan = 2

SWITCH A:
========
vlan 1
untagged eth1
untagged gig0 (can we make it tagged to gig0)?
untagged eth3 (is't required in order pc go to Data vlan)?
vlan 2
untagged eth1
tagged gig0

vlan 3
tagged eth3 (is't required because IP Phone will transfer Data and Voice vlan)?


SWITCHB:
===========
vlan 1
untagged eth1
untagged gig0

vlan 2
untagged eth0
tagged gig0


Is these configuration is ok between 2 HP switches?? and can we "tagged" the Vlan 1 on the port between the 2 switches ??


/////////////
another question what if SWITCH B = cisco , the following config will be like this ?

int gig0
switchport mode trunk
switchport trunk enc dot1q
switchport native vlan 1 (am confuse here, it should be 1 as long as all HP Ports by default are in: untagged vlan 1 ? correct)??
switchport trunk allow vlan 1,2,3

Thanks for Your help

 

[VinceWhirlwind]

You can't have two VLANs untagged on the same port.

The Cisco interface config you display would require the facing Procurve port to be
untagged VLAN1
tagged VLAN 2,3

Yes, on the HP you can make VLAN1 tagged as well, without defining any untagged VLAN on the same interface.
On the Cisco, you have to define a different VLAN as Native in order to make VLAN 1 tagged.

 

[moekad]

Thanks for your reply,

in this case:

if i want native vlan = 1, then on HP vlan 1 should be untagged?? right ?

Thanks in advance

 

[VinceWhirlwind]

Yes