Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations strongm on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Communication Question 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

chiefred

Technical User
Sep 2, 2002
312
US
Obviously because of costs--our business is looking at other alternatives to Nextel's. I am wondering if a 2 way paging system might be more cost effective. Does anyone employ this or have any other ideas? Someone suggested I look at T Mobile as they have a cell--plus text messaging package. The downside is we rely heavily on the Nextels direct connect--both long range and at a site over distance.

Help

Thanks
 
The first question, do you have an existing contract with Nextel? If so, when is it up? If you are still under contract, (depending upon the terms), it could be costly to cancel or downgrade service.

Second question, when you say “two-way paging system”, are you talking about pagers with two way text messaging?

I have found that conversing via a two way pager is cumbersome when trying to conduct business.

A couple thoughts:
If you really rely upon the push to talk feature of Nextel, other carriers offer this option now. Verizon offers a push to talk service, and Sprint has the “Ready Link” service available in most areas. They both have bundled feature rate packages available to the average consumer. They are worth a look. We tested both Verizon PTT and Sprint Ready Link, and found both to be usable. There is a notable difference to Nextel, mainly delay on initial call setup. After the initial call setup, the quality is great. The coverage is better on the Sprint/Verizon options because Nextel is pretty much limited to the metropolitan areas. You get a few miles off a major roadway and you loose the Nextel signal.

I would talk to a business rep from each carrier, and have them quote services to you based upon your typical usage patterns. You may find that you get a better rate from a cell/PCS carrier with PTT features in a pool plan. Pool plans are sometimes the way to go when you have several users with different usage patterns.

One thing to keep in mind, there may be some interesting marketing changes around the bend since Sprint announced their purchase/merger with Nextel. There is no telling what this will do to the offerings from either carrier.
 
Thankyou--a very excellent and informative answer and items for us to consider. I did not know Sprint was considering purchasing Nextel......... interesting--but probably nothing new as services for at least 6-12 months I bet.

Thanks so much
 
Sprint announced the plans to purchase Nextel two weeks ago. I would imagine there would be several SEC and FCC hurdles to jump prior to close. I have heard no plans from either one yet as to future service offerings.
One thing for sure, it should be interesting.

If you are mainly interested in the PTT feature, you might want to talk to a local two-way radio shop to see what they could offer in the two way radio arena. Not sure of the capital involved, but it is worth the look.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top