We have had a similar problem to the one described by adsfx, so I followed the steps given by Shaunmcb but unfortunateately haven't had any luck.
The device analysis test does indeed suggest that the drive may need recalibration, but when this is attempted the recalibration process will fail. The following is a sample of what is logged by the HP Tapetools:
Starting Write Current Recalibration ...
Checking for correct cartridge type ...
Set Buffered Mode: ON ...
Setting write current to 0x28 ..
Writing loop 10 of 120
Writing loop 20 of 120
Loop: 22 ERT value too high .. skip this write!
Setting write current to 0x23 ..
Writing loop 10 of 120
Writing loop 20 of 120
Loop: 22 ERT value too high .. skip this write!
This is logged repeatedly for numerous different "write current" values until finally it fails with the error message "Unable to read at any write current setting!". At this point the LCD panel on the tape drive will display either "Read fail" only, or the same message alternating with "Clean me" (tape drive cleaned over 10 times prior to attempting recalibration).
Would I be correct to think that all this indicates faulty hardware?
Thanks for any response!