Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations strongm on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Best Solution To Track Attendance? Excel vs Access?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mattiekrome

Technical User
Oct 26, 2006
14
US
Hello again. I have been building an excel spreadsheet that will be used to track class attendance. It was working well, until I started trying to track additional information such as addresses (inside of excel comment fields). I am now thinking of scrapping this original idea and look for a new solution. Just getting too big to fit in a spreadsheet (not to mention the problems with my comment fields and frozen panes... argh!)...

Does anyone out there have any suggestions on how to go about this in access? The fields will include (a general idea...):

First name
Last name
Middle initial
Address
City
State
ZIP
Email
Birthdate
etc.

This class will be meeting one time per week. The whole point of this database is to be able to somehow enter whether or not a certain person was in class each week. Once I get several weeks of attendance info entered, I would like to be able to generate a report (with address and phone #) based on who has missed 3 classes in a row.

The biggest thing that I am unable to grasp is how to enter the attendance part. Will I have a field for each week (class meets once per week)? If so, will I have 52 checkboxes on a form (once for each week of the year)? Seems like it would be a little cluttered, lol.

I thought of putting 12 tabs (one for each month) and then having the 52 class meeting days (checkboxes) on said tabs. The drawback of this is all the clicking that has to be done to get to the correct person, then find the correct tab, then put a checkbox on the correct date. Multiply that time 100 people each week and it can become quite time consuming :/

I thought of just entering the attendance data straight into the table, but with the 60+ fields that will be included, it could get a little frustrating. Then I thought of maybe using the form, but adding a search box, where you could type in the first few letters of someone's last name and go straight to their record.

And to make it all more complicated, I will be sharing this "attendance duty" with another older woman who isn't a huge fan of PC's or learning to do anything new with PC's. So it might have to be somewhat user friendly to top it all off.

I have some experience with Access in the past, but its been literally YEARS since I've had to tap into the ol' brain on this sort of thing. I'm sure once I got a plan and got my hands on the tables, I could get something going.

Maybe there is no real simple way to do this, but I thought I would ask, since lots of the posters on here work with this sort of thing everyday. Advice, insight, and direction are greatly appreciated! Thanks!

 
I teach, part time. Being in the technology field, parts of my lessons are automated (using macros - almost like a CBT, but not quite) and all my tests are automated (of course macros); I still find the one piece of paper the best way to keep attendance.

Member- AAAA Association Against Acronym Abusers
 



Hi,

Great that you are asking about design before charging into this task and making alot of mistakes.

Issues to consider:

What information you want to store.
How to store the information?
How to add, change delete information?
What is the process for maintaining the data?

What information you want to report.
How you want to report the information?
What is the process for reporting the data?

Have you ever done stuff like this before? This is not a trivial task.

A tip or two at Tek-Tips will not do you in good stead IMHO. You might consider hiring a reputable consultant to help you develop good requirements and design a system for you. There may even be some off-the-shelf solution that you could condiser.

You could, like many, crutch something together in Excel, but you would be posting questions back here within weeks, about how to get the information out of this that you need.

Skip,
[sub]
[glasses] [red][/red]
[tongue][/sub]
 
Hi,

I love Skip's reply - people too often do first then think, rather than the opposite! Of course it is often very easy to try things out with Excel because it is such a flexible tool.

Have a look at this site and their templates - even if you don't use them they can give some good ideas!


Also checkout:


where there is a list of many templates.

Why re-invent the wheel!

Good Luck!

Peter Moran
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top