Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations IamaSherpa on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Bad shutdown command

Status
Not open for further replies.

kevvyb

Vendor
May 26, 2006
2
GB
Hi

Hope someone may be able to help me.

Have two Maxtor DiamondMax 10 300Gb IDE ATA 133 16MB cache hard drives, XP home on Primary with a number of partitions (boot, op system and data all seperated), secondary hard drive had partitions for copy data, page file and sysimages.

Both hard drives bought at same time,installed August 2005 (purchased June 2005). Basically a hard shutdown appears to have screwed my secondary drive. Here's description of what I've done and where I am:

Also have have a second back up of data on external hard drive.

Running the virus scanner integrated with Comodo 3 for first time tonight. Came back to machine after only a few minutes to find it scanning the second partition on my secondary hard drive. Machine unresponsive, HD activity light permanently lit, machine effectivley crashed. Couldn't stop Comodo Virus scanner. Had a job shutting any apps down and eventually had to do a hard reboot.

On restarting chkdsk ran and reported 6 or so segements as unreadable on the partition of the hard drive that Comodo was scanning. chkdsk then ground to a halt with hd activity light permanently lit.

After a few restarts and trying to boot into last known good config, safe mode etc chkdisk then started to run through the same partition reporting everything as unreadable.

I stopped this by doing another hard reboot (it looked like it might take a long time!) and decided to reformat the offending partition with PM.

On restart chkdsk ran again and has stuck after completing verification of files, index and security descriptor. So effectively locked out of my machine.

Disconnected the Secondary drive and that has allowed me to boot into windows on Primary drive and everything running normally. Created pagefile back onto data partition for time being. Done a current backup of data from Primary to external HD.

Checked secondary drive again with PM8 and offending partition reported an error 1151 "Bad Shutdown Command" I think it said.

Anyways, deleting all partitions on the drive and reformatting the entire disk has eliminated the shutdown error but reconnecting the disk still giving a hang in chkdisk after completing verification of files, index and security descriptor.

Not sure where to go now. Is it worth trying writing zeros to whole disk? Do you think the drive has gone to the great scrapheap in the sky?
 
get the seatools for hd diagnostic from seagate and do a propper check.
i would try a lowlevel format as a last chance to get it back to work
 
If you think about it, 3 yrs of service for a HDD, is pretty good, especially if they are running for any length of time, since it is unknown what that drive was used for, e.g. P2P (eMule & Torrents) would significantly affect HDD liftime expectation...

I would check the S.M.A.R.T. status of said drive, along with Lemon13's suggestion on using SeaTools (Seagate), also SpinRite might help here...

though I would consider that drive as a loss, go out and get another drive (they are pretty inexpensive these days)...

then transfer the DATA from the OLDER drive to the NEWER drive (imaging or cloning) and use the older drive for what you used the damaged one for...


Ben

"If it works don't fix it! If it doesn't use a sledgehammer..."
 
From what you describe it seems the drive has developed bad sectors, and is crashing when attempting to scan them, read them or access them in any way. Bad sectors unfortunately cannot be repaired. Drives usually have backup sectors to automatically replace bad ones should they develop.

These backup sectors are limited and the process is usually transparent to the user.
When the back up sectors have been used up, then you start to see bad sectors pop up here and there. Windows may sometimes be able to mark them as bad and not use them, but usually this kind of problem tends to cascade, so eventually the entire drives is bad.

your last hope yes is to run the manufacturers diagnostic tools, and see if it can isolate the bad sectors, and then run a low level format.


----------------------------------
Ignorance is not necessarily Bliss, case in point:
Unknown has caused an Unknown Error on Unknown and must be shutdown to prevent damage to Unknown.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top